Why Vine died - The Verge

The app generated more beloved memes and cultural moments than most apps with twice as many users — but Twitter's mounting core business ... Skiptomaincontent clock menu more-arrow no yes Tech Video Amazon Apple Facebook Google Microsoft Samsung Tesla AI Cars Cybersecurity Mobile Policy Privacy Scooters AllTech Reviews Phones Laptops Headphones Cameras Tablets Smartwatches Speakers Drones Accessories BuyingGuides How-tos Deals MorefromVergeReviews Science Video Space NASA SpaceX Health Energy Environment AllScience Creators YouTube Instagram Adobe Kickstarter Tumblr ArtClub Cameras Photography What’sinyourbag? AllCreators Entertainment Film TV Games Fortnite GameofThrones Books Comics Music AllEntertainment Video Features Podcasts Newsletters MerchStore ✕ Filedunder: Apps Report Tech WhyVinedied New, 38 comments Closingtheloop By CaseyNewton@CaseyNewton Oct28,2016,12:15pmEDT Sharethisstory SharethisonFacebook SharethisonTwitter Share Allsharingoptions Share Allsharingoptionsfor: WhyVine died Linkedin Reddit Pocket Flipboard Email ThethingaboutVinebecomingtheinternet’spremiertoolformakingshort-formvideosisthatithappenedalmostcompletelybyaccident.Itsfoundershadenvisionedtheirtoolformaking6-secondclipsasawaytohelppeoplecapturecasualmomentsintheirlivesandsharethemwithfriends.ItwaspartoftheirpitchtoTwitter,whichboughtthecompanyforareported$30millioninOctober2012,seeingitasanear-perfectvideoanalogtoitsflagshipapp’sshort-formtextposts. Andyetevenbeforetheapplaunched,usershadtakenthe6-secondconstraintasacreativechallenge.Somethingaboutthatloop—thewayaVineendlesslyrewounditselfaftercompleting,likeaGIFwithaudio—encouragedpeopletoputtheapptostrangeuses.“Itwassurprising,”saidDomHofmann,whofoundedVinewithRusYusupovandColinKrollfourmonthsbeforeTwitterboughtit.“Ouroriginalbetahadsomethinglike10or15peopleonit,andevenwiththatsmallgroupwestartedtoseeexperimentationprettyearlyon.” Withinweeks,itappearedthatVineprobablywouldneverbecometheeverydayvideosharingtoolitsfoundershadenvisioned.Insteaditbecamesomethingwilder—andmuchmoreculturallyinteresting.“Itbecameprettyclearassoonafterwelaunched,”Hofmannsaid.“Watchingthecommunityandthetoolpushoneachotherwasexcitingandunreal,andalmostimmediatelyitbecameclearthatVine’sculturewasgoingtoshifttowardscreativityandexperimentation.” “ItimmediatelybecameclearthatVine’sculturewasgoingtoshifttowardscreativity.”OnThursday,theexperimentationcametoanend.Withitsownfutureincreasinglyuncertain,TwittersaiditwouldshutdownVine’smobileappsometimeinthenextfewmonths.AndwhileexistingVineswillremainontheweb,amediaformatthathadbecomebelovedforitsversatilitynowappearsheadedthewayofBetamax. InterviewswithsevenformerexecutivesrevealaportraitofacompanywhoseculturalimpactfaroutstrippeditsstrategicbenefitstoTwitter.Workingacontinentapartfromtheirparentcompany,Vine’ssmall,NewYork-basedteamstruggledtogrowitsuserbaseorfindwaystomakemoney.WhileVineonceboastedacommandingleadoverothersocialvideoapps,itfailedtokeeppaceascompetitorsaddedfeatures—somethingthatultimatelydroveitsbiggeststarsaway.Theappgeneratedmorebelovedmemesandculturalmomentsthanmostappswithtwiceasmanyusers—butTwitter’smountingcorebusinessproblemsthisyearallbutensureditwouldeventuallybesoldofforshuttered. IanPadghamsawthepotentialinVine—bothcreativeandmonetary—beforealmostanyone.AsamemberofTwitter’smarketingteamin2012,hewasresponsibleformakingvideosthatexplainedhowtheserviceworked.(HisearlyfilmaboutworkingatTwitterislikelyoneofthemost-watchedrecruitingvideosevermade.)AfterTwitterboughtVine,hesatinonmeetingswiththemarketingteamandbegantoexploreitspotentialasacreativetool. Padgham’sfirstVinewasasimpletime-lapsevideooftheviewfromhiswindowatTwitter.Helovedthe6-secondlimit,whichforcedhimtothinkdifferentlyaboutstorytelling.“It’skindoflikedrawinginMicrosoftPaint,”hesaid.“Itusedtobetheworstappever,butyoucouldn’tgetdistractedbythebellsandwhistles.” “Youcouldn’tgetdistractedbythebellsandwhistles.” PadghambeganmakingVineseverydaybeforeheleftforwork,andtheysoongrewbothinpopularityandinambition.Hecutout300photoprintsandspentthreehourspainstakinglyturningthemintoatributetoEadweardMuybridge,aphotographerwhodidpioneeringworkinmotionpictures.HestoodunderneathBigBenandrecordedatimelapseofhimselfappearingtomovethehandsoftheclockwithhisfingers,aloopthatwasviewedmorethan5milliontimes.SoonbrandslikeSonyandAirbnbwerecontactingPadghamaskinghimtomakeVinesontheirbehalf,andsixmonthsafterVinelaunchedhequitTwittertodoitfulltime. In2013,Vinebeganallowinguserstorecordclipswiththeirphones’front-facingcameras,andusageexploded.Anecosystemofyoungstarssprunguparoundtheservice,whichevolvedintoakindoflive-actioncartoonnetwork.TherewasZachKing,whoseeye-poppingmagictricksearnedhim4millionfollowersandmorethan1.4billionviews.OrAmandaCerny,whosephysicalcomedyearnedmorethan2.2billionviews.LoganPaul,whoseVinesloopedmorethan4billiontimes,parlayedhisfollowingintoaseriesofactingroles—whileearning$200,000tocreateasingleVineforabrand,accordingtoarecent60Minutesreport. Ina2014lookathowvideoplatformswerecreatingthenextgenerationofcelebrities,TheNewYorkerputVineatthecenter.“AVine’sblink-quicktransience,combinedwithitsendlesslooping,simultaneouslysqueezestimeandstretchesit,”TadFriendwrote.Theappgeneratedcountlessmemes,andgrewincreasinglyself-referentialovertime,sothatasingle6-secondclipmightreferenceadozenprevioushitVines.Andyetinretrospectitseemsclearthat2014waswhenVinepeaked.Researchfirm7ParkDatasays3.64percentofallAndroidusersopenedVineinAugust2014;todaythatnumberhasfallento0.66percent.(TwitterneversaidhowmanypeopleusedVine,butonceclaimedithadanaudienceof200millionpeopleontheweb.) FormerexecutivessaythatamajorcompetitivechallengedemergedintheformofInstagram,whichintroduced15-secondvideoclipsinJune2013.“Instagramvideowasthebeginningoftheend,”oneformerexecutivetoldme.“[Vine]didn’tmovefastenoughtodifferentiate.”Instagramcourtedcelebritieswithlongervideos,eventuallybumpingthelimittoamoreflexible60seconds.(Vinesdidn’tbreakthe6-secondbarrieruntilearlierthisyear,anditsextendedvideosnevercaughton.)Instagramalsobeganpromotingcelebrityaccountsinitspopular“explore”tab,bringingthemattentionthatVinefounddifficulttomatch.MarketersbeganshiftingtheirmoneyawayfromVine,andstarsfollowed. “Vinedidn’tmovefastenoughtodifferentiate.”MeanwhileSnapchat,whichalloweduserstosendeachother10-secondvideoclipsand(later)broadcastthempublicly,ultimatelybecamethecasualmass-marketlifecastingappthatVine’sfoundershadoncepitchedtheirproducttoTwitteras.Whenotherplatformssurgedahead,someVinestarsbegannegotiatingtobepaidtopostontheservice.Butthetalksstalled,andbyMaytheWashingtonPostfoundthatVineuserswithlargefollowingsweresharingnewvideosmuchlessfrequently. Atthemanagementlevel,Vinewasrarelystableforlong.Hofmannquitin2014topursueanewstartup.Krollfollowedhimoutthedoorlaterthatyear.TwitterlaidoffYusupov,whowasVine’screativedirector,aspartoflastyear’smasslayoffs.(“Don’tsellyourcompany!”,hetweetedonThursday.)JasonTofftookoverVinein2014andleditfortwoyearsbeforequittingthisyeartoworkonvirtualrealityprojectsatGoogle.HannahDonovanbecamegeneralmanagerinMarchafterworkingataseriesofmusicstartups.HerlackofpreviousexperiencerunningacompanyledsomeemployeesIspokewithtoquestionwhetherherhiringmightbethebeginningoftheend. YearsofexecutivechurnlikelycontributedtoVine’sfailuretomakemoney.Forawhile,brandswerehappytopayVinestarsdirectlytomakeadsandsharethemtotheirmillionsoffollowers.ButafterSnapchatandInstagramgrewintohundredsofmillionsofdailyusers,marketers’interestinVinedroppedsignificantly.Theyhadoncelongedforwaystogrowtheirownfollowingsontheapp—throughpaidplacementofferingssimilartoTwitter’spromotedtweetsandpromotedaccounts.ButVinenevercamethroughwithanyoptions,inpartbecausethefoundersresistedmonetizationfromthestart,sourcessaid.Itnevertookacutofstars’dealswithbrands,althoughTwitterboughtasocialmediatalentagencylastyearinhopesitcouldbegintodosoindirectly. Bythisyear,TwitterexecutiveswerediscussingwaystobringTwitter’svariousvideoofferingstogethersomehow,sourcessaid.InJune,thecompanyhelddiscussionsaboutabsorbingVineintoTwitter’sflagshipapp.ToVineemployees,thosediscussionsservedasevidencethatTwitternevervaluedVineasastandalonepropertythewayitsaudiencedid.ButnoVineintegrationevermaterialized,andthissummertopVineexecutivesbeganheadingfortheexits.Twitterexploredsellingtheapp,accordingtotheNewYorkTimes,butitneverfoundabuyer. “Vinedidn’tshipanythingofconsequenceforayear.” “AcoupleofthingsplaguedVine,anditallstemsfromthesamething,whichisalackofunityandleadershiponavision,”saidAnkurThakkar,whowasVine’sheadofeditorialfrom2014untilMayofthisyear.Hetoldmehewasproudoftheworktheappdidtohighlightrisingstars,includingRuthB,whoearnedarecorddealafterhisteamgaveheracoveted“editor’spick”award.Butbytheendthecompanywasrudderless,hesaid.“Thattrickleddownintoalloftheprojectteamsandthethingstheywereworkingon,”hesaid.“Vinedidn’tshipanythingofconsequenceforayear.” ThestarswhogrewfamousonVinecontinuepostingtheirworkonotherplatforms.Butthey’renolongerpushingthesurprisinglyelasticboundariesofthe6-secondmedium.“ThemostimportantofpartofVinehasalwaysbeenthepeoplethatareonit,”DomHofmanntoldme.“It’salsotheonlypartthatcan’tbereplicated.SoI’mgoingtomissthem.EventhoughIcananddofollowsomepeoplefromVineonInstagramorSnapchatorTwitterorwhereverthey’vedecidedtogo,itjustdoesn’tfeelthesame.It’slikethebandisbreakingupandeveryone’sgoingsolo.” NextUpIn Tech Signupforthe newsletter VergeDeals SubscribetogetthebestVerge-approvedtechdealsoftheweek. Justonemorething! PleaseconfirmyoursubscriptiontoVergeDealsviatheverificationemailwejustsentyou. Email(required) Bysubmittingyouremail,youagreetoourTermsandPrivacyNotice.Youcanoptoutatanytime.ThissiteisprotectedbyreCAPTCHAandtheGooglePrivacyPolicyandTermsofServiceapply. Subscribe Loadingcomments... Sharethisstory Twitter Facebook